Co-Signers in a Wisconsin Chapter 13: The Codebtor Stay, the Twenty-Day Trap, and Why Chapter 7 Does Nothing for Them

A parent co-signs a car loan. A sister guarantees a credit card so a brother can rebuild his credit. A friend puts their name on a furniture contract that was never going to be paid. Years later the borrower files chapter 13 — and the first telephone call the creditor makes is not to the debtor. It is to the co-signer, who did nothing wrong, is not in bankruptcy, and has just discovered that generosity has a collections department.

Congress anticipated exactly this. Section 1301 of the Bankruptcy Code is a second automatic stay, separate from the familiar one, and it exists for one purpose: to stop a creditor from squeezing the debtor indirectly by squeezing the people who signed for them. It is also one of the most misunderstood provisions in consumer bankruptcy, because its protection is narrower than it sounds, it can be switched off on twenty days’ notice, and it does not exist at all in chapter 7.

What the codebtor stay actually says

Section 1301 (a) provides that, except as provided in subsections (b) and (c), after the order for relief under chapter 13 a creditor “may not act, or commence or continue any civil action, to collect all or any part of a consumer debt of the debtor from any individual that is liable on such debt with the debtor, or that secured such debt,” unless that individual became liable on or secured the debt in the ordinary course of their business, or the case is closed, dismissed, or converted to a case under chapter 7 or 11.

Read the verbs. The prohibition is not merely on lawsuits. A creditor may not act to collect — which reaches the dunning letter, the telephone call, the demand on a co-signer’s bank. The stay arises automatically on the order for relief; nobody has to ask for it, and it is not a remedy the co-signer petitions the court to receive.

The purpose was stated plainly when the section was written. House Report No. 95–595 describes § 1301 as designed to protect a chapter 13 debtor “by insulating him from indirect pressures from his creditors exerted through friends or relatives that may have cosigned an obligation of the debtor.” The same report is equally plain about the limit of the kindness: the creditor “is delayed, but his substantive rights are not affected.” That sentence is the whole design. Section 1301 buys time, not forgiveness.

The section dates to the original 1978 Code (Pub. L. 95–598, 92 Stat. 2645) and was amended in 1984 (Pub. L. 98–353). It has been stable for four decades, which is worth knowing because the advice circulating about it is often older than the reader.

Four limits that decide whether it reaches your case

It covers consumer debt only. Section 1301 (a) reaches “a consumer debt of the debtor,” and § 101 (8) defines consumer debt as “debt incurred by an individual primarily for a personal, family, or household purpose.” A co-signed car note or credit card is squarely inside. A co-signed business line of credit, an equipment lease for a landscaping operation, a personal guaranty of a company obligation — these are outside, and the co-signer on them has no protection from this section at all. The purpose test looks at why the money was borrowed, not at who signed.

It protects individuals only. The statutory word is “individual.” A corporate guarantor, an LLC that signed as an accommodation, a business entity that pledged collateral — none is an individual, and none is shielded. Where a family business guaranteed a family member’s consumer loan, the human co-signer may be protected and the entity may not.

The ordinary-course-of-business exception removes the professionals. Section 1301 (a) (1) withdraws the stay where the individual “became liable on or secured such debt in the ordinary course of such individual’s business.” A commercial surety is in the business of guaranteeing obligations and is left where the contract put it. A mother who signed once, for one child, is not.

It exists only in chapter 13. Section 1301 appears in chapter 13 and operates “after the order for relief under this chapter.” Chapter 7 contains no equivalent. This is the single most consequential point in the article and the one most often gotten backwards at the kitchen table: a chapter 7 filing does nothing whatever for a co-signer. The debtor walks out discharged and the creditor turns, undisturbed, to whoever else signed. If protecting a co-signer matters to the outcome, that consideration belongs in the choice of chapter, before the petition is filed.

The creditor has three exits, and the court must open them

Section 1301 (c) is not discretionary. On request of a party in interest and after notice and a hearing, the court “shall grant relief from the stay” with respect to a creditor to the extent that:

  • § 1301 (c) (1) — as between the debtor and the individual protected by the stay, that individual received the consideration for the claim. In other words, the nominal borrower was the real accommodation party. Where a father signed for a car his son drives and the son is now in chapter 13 claiming the father’s protection, the question is who got the car.
  • § 1301 (c) (2) — the plan filed by the debtor proposes not to pay the claim. This is the common one, and it is the reason the plan’s treatment of co-signed debt is the real battleground.
  • § 1301 (c) (3) — the creditor’s interest would be irreparably harmed by continuation of the stay.

Note the recurring phrase “to the extent that.” Relief under this subsection is proportional, not binary. A plan proposing to pay sixty percent of a co-signed claim does not hand the creditor the whole co-signer; it opens the door to the part the plan leaves unpaid.

The twenty-day trap

Here is the provision that catches people, and it catches them by silence rather than by argument.

Section 1301 (d) provides that twenty days after the filing of a request under subsection (c) (2) for relief from the codebtor stay, “such stay is terminated with respect to the party in interest making such request, unless the debtor or any individual that is liable on such debt with the debtor files and serves upon such party in interest a written objection to the taking of the proposed action.”

No hearing. No order. No judicial finding that the creditor is entitled to anything. A creditor who files the request and waits out the clock gets the co-signer back by operation of the statute. The only thing that stops it is a written objection, filed and served, within twenty days.

Two features of that sentence deserve emphasis. First, the objection may be filed by the debtor or by any individual liable on the debt — so the co-signer has standing to defend themselves, and does not depend on the debtor’s diligence. Second, the burden of motion has been inverted. Everywhere else in the stay provisions the creditor must move and the court must rule; here, inaction by the protected parties is consent.

The practical instruction follows directly. A co-signer who receives papers from a creditor in a relative’s chapter 13 case should not file them in a drawer and assume the bankruptcy is handling it. Twenty days is a short calendar, and the consequence of letting it run is not a lost argument but a lost stay.

The plan is the real protection

Because § 1301 (c) (2) ties relief to what the plan proposes to pay, the durable protection for a co-signer is not the stay. It is the plan.

Chapter 13 plans ordinarily may not discriminate unfairly among classes of unsecured creditors. Section 1322 (b) (1) carves out a specific exception for precisely this problem: a plan may designate classes of unsecured claims as provided in § 1122 and may not discriminate unfairly against any class so designated, “however, such plan may treat claims for a consumer debt of the debtor if an individual is liable on such consumer debt with the debtor differently than other unsecured claims.”

That clause is the drafting tool. A plan may propose to pay a co-signed consumer debt in full while paying other unsecured creditors a fraction, and the ordinary objection — that favoring one unsecured creditor over another is unfair discrimination — is answered by the statute itself. Pay the co-signed claim in full and § 1301 (c) (2) has nothing to work on, because the plan does not propose not to pay it.

Whether a particular plan can afford that treatment is a different question, and it is an arithmetic question rather than a legal one. It depends on disposable income, on the size of the co-signed balance relative to the rest of the unsecured pool, and on confirmation requirements that this article does not reach. But the debtor who tells their lawyer at the first meeting that the point of filing is to keep a creditor off their mother has given the lawyer something to work with. The debtor who mentions it after confirmation has not.

Did someone co-sign a debt you are about to file on? The rules are mechanical. Applying them to your actual balance sheet is not. Carson Law Office has practiced in Milwaukee and Waukesha County for over thirty years. Call (262) 860-8932 or schedule a consultation.

Dismissal and conversion end it immediately

Section 1301 (a) (2) withdraws the stay where the case is closed, dismissed, or converted to a case under chapter 7 or 11. Each of those is a live risk in a chapter 13, and the last one is entirely within the debtor’s control.

Section 1307 (a) provides that the debtor “may convert a case under this chapter to a case under chapter 7 of this title at any time,” and that any waiver of that right is unenforceable. A debtor who gives up partway through a multi-year plan and converts to chapter 7 has, in the same motion, removed every protection the co-signer had. The debtor cannot contract that right away, so no promise to a co-signer can secure it.

Dismissal operates the same way and is the more common ending. A plan that fails for nonpayment is dismissed, the codebtor stay evaporates with it, and the creditor resumes collection against the co-signer for whatever remains — with the contractual interest and fees that accrued while everyone waited.

Completing the plan does not discharge the co-signer

This is the hardest thing to tell a co-signer, and it is unambiguous.

Section 1328 (a) grants the debtor, on completion of all payments under the plan and subject to its own conditions and exceptions, a discharge of all debts provided for by the plan or disallowed under § 502. That discharge runs to the debtor. Section 524 (e) states the limit: except as provided in § 524 (a) (3), “discharge of a debt of the debtor does not affect the liability of any other entity on, or the property of any other entity for, such debt.”

So where a plan paid forty percent of a co-signed consumer debt and the debtor received a discharge, the debtor is free and the co-signer owes the remaining sixty percent. The co-signer received the benefit of the payments the plan made — the balance is genuinely smaller — but the obligation was never theirs to discharge, and nothing in the debtor’s case extinguished it. This is why a plan that pays co-signed debt in full is worth real effort: it is the only path on which the co-signer walks away clean at the end.

The Wisconsin wrinkle: the spouse who never signed

Wisconsin adds a complication that does not arise in most states, and it is not a § 1301 problem at all. It is frequently mistaken for one.

Wisconsin is a marital property state. Under Wis. Stat. § 766.55 (1), an obligation incurred by a spouse during marriage, including one attributable to an act or omission during marriage, “is presumed to be incurred in the interest of the marriage or the family.” Section 766.55 (2) (b) then provides that such an obligation “may be satisfied only from all marital property and all other property of the incurring spouse.”

The consequence is that a Wisconsin spouse who never signed anything may nevertheless find marital property — including marital income — available to satisfy the other spouse’s family-purpose debt. Related provisions do similar work: § 766.555 governs obligations incurred under open-end credit plans, the category most consumer credit cards occupy, and § 766.56 (3) (b) requires a creditor who extends credit to a spouse in a transaction governed by chs. 421 to 427 to give the nonapplicant spouse written notice of the extension of credit before any payment is due, where the extension may result in an obligation described under § 766.55 (2) (b).

The distinction to hold onto is this. Section 1301 protects an individual who is liable on the debt with the debtor. The marital property statute does not make the nonincurring spouse liable on the obligation; it determines which property is available to satisfy it. Those are different mechanisms, and they do not map onto each other. A non-filing Wisconsin spouse should not assume the codebtor stay answers a marital-property collection question, and a creditor reaching marital property is not necessarily doing the thing § 1301 (a) forbids. Where a spouse’s exposure arises under ch. 766 rather than from a signature, the analysis belongs to a lawyer with both statutes open, and the answer will depend on facts this article cannot supply.

One further provision is worth knowing because it surprises people after a divorce. Section 766.55 (2m) provides that, unless the dissolution decree or an amendment to it provides otherwise, no income of a nonincurring spouse is available for satisfaction of an obligation under sub. (2) (b) after entry of the decree, and marital property assigned to each spouse under the decree is available only to the extent of its value at the date of the decree. The decree closes the door going forward; it does not retroactively undo what was reachable before.

The practical sequence

For a debtor who cares about a co-signer, the order of operations is fixed and it starts earlier than most people think:

  • Raise it before the chapter is chosen. Section 1301 has no chapter 7 counterpart. The decision between chapter 7 and chapter 13 is where co-signer protection is won or lost.
  • Identify every co-signed and guaranteed obligation at the first meeting — and whether each was incurred for a personal, family, or household purpose under § 101 (8), because that is what determines whether § 1301 touches it.
  • Treat the co-signed consumer claim in the plan. Section 1322 (b) (1) permits it. Paying the claim in full is what both removes the § 1301 (c) (2) exit and leaves the co-signer discharged in fact at the end, since § 524 (e) will not do it for them.
  • Calendar the twenty days. When a creditor files under § 1301 (c) (2), the stay ends by operation of § 1301 (d) unless an objection is filed and served. Either the debtor or the co-signer may file it.
  • Do not let the case fail quietly. Dismissal and conversion both terminate the stay under § 1301 (a) (2), and § 1307 (a) makes the right to convert unwaivable.

And for the co-signer reading this because a relative has filed: the protection is real, it is automatic, and it is not permanent. The creditor is delayed, as the 1978 House Report said, and no more. What determines whether you end the case owing nothing is not the stay. It is what the plan proposes to pay you, and whether anyone thought to ask for that in time.

Talk to a New Berlin bankruptcy attorney

Carson Law Office handles chapter 7 and chapter 13 bankruptcy in New Berlin, Waukesha County, Milwaukee, West Allis, Wauwatosa, and the surrounding communities — including chapter 13 plans drafted to protect a co-signer under § 1322 (b) (1), objections to codebtor-stay relief under § 1301 (c) and (d), and the Wisconsin marital property questions under ch. 766 that arise when only one spouse files. If someone co-signed for you, the choice between chapter 7 and chapter 13 is the decision that determines whether they are protected at all. Call (262) 860-8932 or email christopher@carsonlawoffice.com. You can also read more about our bankruptcy practice, our post on the automatic stay under § 362, and our post on chapter 7 versus chapter 13 in Wisconsin, or contact us to arrange a consultation.

Carson Law Office · 15350 West National Avenue, Suite 101, New Berlin, WI 53151 · (262) 860-8932

This article is general information about federal bankruptcy law and Wisconsin marital property law and is not legal advice. Statutes are amended from time to time, reported decisions are subject to further review, and every case turns on its own facts. Speak with an attorney about your own case.

Learn More From Us