The Criminal Complaint in Wisconsin: What It Must Say, and What Makes It Defective

Almost every Wisconsin criminal case begins with a document the defendant is handed in the first five minutes of the first hearing and then never reads again. It is two or three pages. It is written in the flat, clause-heavy voice of a prosecutor working at speed. And it is, in the strict sense, the case: the charge, the facts the State says support it, and the name of whoever swore to them. Everything that follows — the bail decision, the preliminary hearing, the plea negotiation, the trial — is built on top of it.

Wisconsin law has a good deal to say about what that document must contain, and rather less than defendants hope about what happens when it falls short. Both halves of that are worth knowing.

What the statute actually requires

Section 968.01 (2) of the Wisconsin Statutes runs three sentences, and the first does most of the work: the complaint “is a written statement of the essential facts constituting the offense charged.” The other two add things people find surprising. First, “A person may make a complaint on information and belief” — the complainant need not have seen anything personally, and in practice the complainant is usually an officer reciting what witnesses and reports told him. Second, the complaint must be made upon oath before a district attorney or a judge. Subsections (3) and (4) allow that oath to be taken by telephone, with the signed statement transmitted afterward by facsimile or sent electronically with an electronic signature.

Issuance is a separate step from drafting, and it belongs to one office. Under § 968.02 (1), a complaint charging a person with an offense “shall be issued only by a district attorney of the county where the crime is alleged to have been committed,” and “[a] complaint is issued when it is approved for filing by the district attorney,” by written endorsement or electronic signature. A police report is not a charge. An arrest is not a charge. Until a prosecutor signs, there is no case.

Then § 968.02 (2): after issuance the complaint is filed with a judge, and “[s]uch filing commences the action.” There is a narrow exception in § 968.02 (3) for the situation where the district attorney declines — a circuit judge may permit a complaint to be filed on a finding of probable cause after a hearing, which the statute specifies “shall be ex parte without the right of cross-examination.”

The judge’s screen, and why dismissal often is not the end

Filing puts the complaint in front of a judge for a probable-cause determination. Under § 968.04 (1), if it appears from the complaint — or from affidavits filed with it, or from examination of the complainant under oath where the judge finds that necessary — that there is probable cause to believe an offense was committed and that the accused committed it, the judge issues a warrant or a summons in its place.

If the judge does not so find, § 968.03 (1) directs the judge to endorse that finding on the complaint and file it with the clerk. That sounds like a win, and it is a real one. It is also, by the express terms of § 968.03 (3), a dismissal “without prejudice.” The State may draft a better complaint and file again. This is the single most important thing to understand about attacking a charging document in Wisconsin, and it is the thing least often explained: the usual remedy for a defective complaint is a better complaint.

The five questions

The phrase “essential facts” has been given a usable test. As the Wisconsin Supreme Court put it in State v. Reed, 2005 WI 53, 280 Wis. 2d 68, 695 N.W.2d 315, a court looks within the four corners of the complaint “to see whether there are facts or reasonable inferences set forth that are sufficient to allow a reasonable person to conclude that a crime was probably committed and that the defendant probably committed it.” And a complaint is sufficient if it answers five questions:

“(1) Who is charged?; (2) What is the person charged with?; (3) When and where did the alleged offense take place?; (4) Why is this particular person being charged?; and (5) Who says so? or how reliable is the informant?”

Reed drew that formulation from State v. White, 97 Wis. 2d 193, 295 N.W.2d 346 (1980), which drew it in turn from the case where the idea started. In State ex rel. Evanow v. Seraphim, 40 Wis. 2d 223, 161 N.W.2d 369 (1968) — decided under the predecessor statute, which used the same operative words — the court borrowed the journalist’s Five W’s and said plainly what a complaint is not for. A defendant is not entitled to “some encyclopedic listing of all evidentiary facts upon which the state intends to rely for his conviction.” The statute “requires only that essential facts be set forth, preferably concisely and certainly clearly.”

The fifth question is the one that does the most work in practice, and Evanow is where its content lies. Because § 968.01 (2) permits a complaint on information and belief, the complainant is usually an officer repeating what someone else told him — and Evanow held that where a complaint rests on information and belief, this requires the setting forth of “enough underlying facts to permit the reasonable inference that the sources of information are probably truthful.” A complaint reciting that an officer believes a crime occurred, without saying how he came to believe it or from whom, has not answered the fifth question.

The standard of review is forgiving, and Evanow said so in the same breath. The question is whether the document meets “the test of minimal adequacy, not in a hypertechnical but in a common sense evaluation, in setting forth the essential facts establishing probable cause.” Evanow itself conceded that the complaint before it was “no model of careful draftsmanship” — and affirmed. Anyone selling the five-question test as a reliable route to dismissal is selling the wrong half of the case.

Four corners

One rule does real work for the defense. A Wisconsin complaint is a self-contained charge: the facts establishing probable cause must appear within the four corners of the document itself, and it is the document alone that the court considers. State v. Haugen, 52 Wis. 2d 791, 191 N.W.2d 12 (1971), which Reed applied on the same terms in 2005. The State cannot patch a thin complaint at the hearing with what the officer knows but did not write down. Evanow noted that this differs from federal practice, where supporting affidavits may be used to make the showing.

Affidavits can be brought inside the four corners, but only by incorporation. In State v. Smaxwell, 2000 WI App 112, 235 Wis. 2d 230, 612 N.W.2d 756, the court of appeals held that only affidavits specifically incorporated into the complaint may be used to show probable cause — while declining to require the formula “incorporated by reference,” holding that “attached” sufficed.

Have you actually read the complaint filed against you? The statute sets the range; what happens inside it turns on facts no article can know. Carson Law Office has practiced in Milwaukee and Waukesha County for over thirty years. Call (262) 860-8932 or schedule a consultation.

What makes a complaint genuinely defective

The clearest defect is a complaint that charges in the words of the statute and stops. In State v. Williams, 47 Wis. 2d 242, 177 N.W.2d 611 (1970), the Wisconsin Supreme Court held a complaint fatally defective where it merely repeated the language of the statute allegedly violated, because it therefore contained no essential facts at all. That principle is not absolute, and the qualification matters: in State v. Smith, 50 Wis. 2d 460, 184 N.W.2d 889 (1971), a complaint for resisting arrest stated in statutory language was held sufficient without further facts. Where the statutory words themselves describe conduct with enough particularity, repeating them can do the job; where they state a legal conclusion, it cannot.

Two other defects recur. A complaint must allege every element, including a mental state where the offense requires one — State v. Schneider, 60 Wis. 2d 563, 211 N.W.2d 630 (1973), held that a charge of acting “feloniously” did not suffice to allege the knowledge element of an obscenity offense. And a complaint may be attacked for the omission of critical material whose inclusion was necessary for an impartial judge to determine probable cause. State v. Mann, 123 Wis. 2d 375, 367 N.W.2d 209 (1985). What was left out can matter as much as what was put in.

The harmless-error wall

Against all of that stand two statutes that defeat most complaints about a charging document, and they should be read before anyone gets their hopes up.

Section 971.26 provides that no complaint or warrant “shall be invalid, nor shall the trial, judgment or other proceedings be affected by reason of any defect or imperfection in matters of form which do not prejudice the defendant.” Wrong date, wrong subsection number, misdescribed statute: if the defendant was not actually misled, the defect is form, and form does not void a case.

Section 971.31 (8) is broader still: no complaint “shall be dismissed or reversed for any error or mistake where the case and the identity of the defendant may be readily understood by the court; and the court may order an amendment curing such defects.” Where the motion rests on a misnomer, § 971.31 (7) directs the court to amend the complaint “forthwith” and require the defendant to plead to it. Even a successful motion to dismiss for a defect in the complaint allows the court under § 971.31 (6) to continue custody or bail for not more than 72 hours pending a new summons, warrant, or complaint.

Amendment is easy early and harder late. Under § 971.29 (1), a complaint may be amended at any time prior to arraignment without leave of the court at all.

The deadline that decides whether any of this is available

All of the above is worth nothing after a certain date, and the date arrives early.

Section 971.31 (2) provides that objections based on defects in the institution of the proceedings or the insufficiency of the complaint “shall be raised before trial by motion or be deemed waived.” Section 971.31 (5) (a) sets the clock: motions before trial are to be served and filed within 10 days after the initial appearance in a misdemeanor action, or within 10 days after arraignment in a felony action, unless the court permits otherwise.

Then the provision that catches people. Section 971.31 (5) (c): “In felony actions, objections based on the insufficiency of the complaint shall be made prior to the preliminary examination or waiver thereof or be deemed waived.” In a felony, the challenge is gone once the preliminary hearing happens — or once it is waived, which in a great many cases is the first thing that happens, sometimes at a hearing the defendant attended without counsel. The Wisconsin Supreme Court held to the same effect in Day v. State, 52 Wis. 2d 122, 187 N.W.2d 790 (1971): a defendant waives objections to the sufficiency of a complaint by not objecting before or at the time of pleading to the information.

Which is why the document handed over at the initial appearance deserves more than a glance. Section 970.02 (1) (a) requires the judge at that appearance to inform the defendant of the charge and to “furnish the defendant with a copy of the complaint which shall contain the possible penalties for the offenses set forth therein.” That copy is the thing to read on the way out of the courthouse, not the thing to put in a drawer. The window for saying anything about it is measured in days, and in a felony it may close at the next hearing on the calendar.

What a complaint challenge is actually for

Honestly stated, a motion attacking the complaint rarely ends a case. Dismissal under § 968.03 is without prejudice; defects of form are cured by § 971.26 and § 971.31 (8); and the State can amend freely before arraignment. What a careful reading of the complaint does accomplish is narrower and more useful: it establishes early which facts the State has actually committed itself to in writing, it exposes elements the prosecutor has assumed rather than alleged, it tests whether the hearsay sources behind an information-and-belief charge were ever identified at all, and it occasionally forces the State to refile on a theory it would rather not have had to write down. Those are leverage, not victory. In a system where most cases resolve by negotiation, leverage is most of what there is.

Talk to a New Berlin criminal defense attorney

Carson Law Office handles misdemeanor and felony defense in New Berlin, Waukesha County, Milwaukee, West Allis, Wauwatosa, and the surrounding communities — including the early motion practice under § 971.31 where the sufficiency of the complaint is still on the table. If you have been charged, the complaint you were handed at your initial appearance is the document to bring to the first meeting, and the deadlines attached to it are short. Call (262) 860-8932 or email christopher@carsonlawoffice.com. You can also read more about our criminal defense practice, our post on the preliminary hearing in a Wisconsin felony case, and our post on the ten-day deadline for motions to suppress, or contact us to arrange a consultation.

Carson Law Office · 15350 West National Avenue, Suite 101, New Berlin, WI 53151 · (262) 860-8932

This article is general information about Wisconsin criminal procedure and is not legal advice. Statutes are amended from time to time, reported decisions are subject to further review, and every case turns on its own facts. Speak with an attorney about your own case.

Learn More From Us